Angående James Potter
Forum > Harry Potter > Angående James Potter
| Användare | Inlägg |
|---|---|
|
soratanaka
Elev |
"At Hogwarts, James was very popular; he was a Quidditch chaser (Sch2) and rather liked to show off (OP28 )."
"In the books, (which i believe are the REAL Harry Potter) it isn't explicitly said exactly which position James Potter played, however J K Rowling has provided information which can be found on many reputable websites that he was one of the three CHASERS and not, in fact, a SEEKER. The idea that he was a seeker was incorporated into the Harry Potter movies, and does not, as so many things in the movie do not, correlate with the books. "No offence to whoever wrote this answer, but book five, the Order of the Phoenix suggests that James played as Seeker as he is sat at the tree with the rest of the Marauders, catching a Golden Snitch that he stole from a Quidditch match. "This note was taken directly from the Harry Potter Lexicon website and states: In the first film, James was said to be a Seeker (PS/f), but JKR stated that he was a Chaser in the second Scholastic interview. Yes, the editors are aware that on a summer's day when he was 15 he was fooling around with a Golden Snitch - much more effective to impress girls than a Quaffle, of course, and something that proves nothing about which position he actually played. JKR said in Sch2 that James was a Chaser, so until she explicitly says otherwise, her word goes." "We should love people and use things, but unfortunately we love things and use people." 1 mar, 2011 17:15 |
|
Protego
Elev |
Skrivet av soratanaka: "At Hogwarts, James was very popular; he was a Quidditch chaser (Sch2) and rather liked to show off (OP28 )." "In the books, (which i believe are the REAL Harry Potter) it isn't explicitly said exactly which position James Potter played, however J K Rowling has provided information which can be found on many reputable websites that he was one of the three CHASERS and not, in fact, a SEEKER. The idea that he was a seeker was incorporated into the Harry Potter movies, and does not, as so many things in the movie do not, correlate with the books. "No offence to whoever wrote this answer, but book five, the Order of the Phoenix suggests that James played as Seeker as he is sat at the tree with the rest of the Marauders, catching a Golden Snitch that he stole from a Quidditch match. "This note was taken directly from the Harry Potter Lexicon website and states: In the first film, James was said to be a Seeker (PS/f), but JKR stated that he was a Chaser in the second Scholastic interview. Yes, the editors are aware that on a summer's day when he was 15 he was fooling around with a Golden Snitch - much more effective to impress girls than a Quaffle, of course, and something that proves nothing about which position he actually played. JKR said in Sch2 that James was a Chaser, so until she explicitly says otherwise, her word goes." Ojj :o
1 mar, 2011 17:20 |
|
soratanaka
Elev |
Såatteh. . . Han spelade som jagare, men i filmerna så visar de sökare.
"We should love people and use things, but unfortunately we love things and use people." 1 mar, 2011 17:32 |
|
Borttagen
|
Stod det inte i någon av böckerna att han är sökare..?
2 mar, 2011 17:27 |
|
soratanaka
Elev |
^ Nej?
"We should love people and use things, but unfortunately we love things and use people." 2 mar, 2011 19:58 |
|
superman
Elev |
jag fattar verkligen inte meningen med att han är sökare i filmen... enda sen jag var liten har jag ansett att scenen där hermione visar harry att hans pappa var sökare väldigt onödig! det är sjukt konstigt att dom lägger in fakta som skiljer sig från boken som utfyllnadsscen
3 mar, 2011 01:51 |
|
Hotissue
Elev |
Haha gode gud! Känner mig helt grundlurad :O har aldrig tänkt på det förut så blev helt glad över att det fortfarande finns "nya" saker att upptäcka, även om man gillat Harry Potter i 10 år
http://loca.blo.gg/ || PotionSnitch169@Pottermore
3 mar, 2011 03:19 |
|
Layla Catcher
Elev |
Jag har alltid trott att han var sökare, precis som Harry, men där hade jag fel....Jag har blivit lurad
3 mar, 2011 07:11 |
|
Soz
Elev |
Det var någotning nytt!
Sherlockian, Whovian etc. 3 mar, 2011 08:35 |
|
soratanaka
Elev |
Har även tänkt på hans position i laget sedan tidigare. Innan jag visste att han faktiskt spelade som Jagare förundrades jag över hans kroppsbyggnad. Jag hade alltid tänkt honom som lite musklig och något tung på grund av det. Inte för att det står i böckerna, tror jag, men det är så jag hade tänkt honom. Då kunde han ju inte spela som Sökare på samma sätt som Harry, imo. Jag trodde han spelade som Slagman, faktiskt. Haha. ~
"We should love people and use things, but unfortunately we love things and use people." 3 mar, 2011 11:36 |
Du får inte svara på den här tråden.



Mugglarportalen